•  
  • News
  • World of Blood Series Removed from Facebook

World of Blood Series Removed from Facebook

by David Angel Published on: May 5, 2009
Comments: Comments Off
Tags: ,
Categories:News

Try to play a World of Blood Series game, such as Elven Blood, on Facebook and you’ll find it is gone. Gone with a capital “Removed from Facebook Entirely.”

Inside Facebook reports on April 9, 2009, in Facebook Removes Developer of Elven Blood from the Platform that the Royal East India Trading Company was a moniker for the developer Patrick Shyu, who along with his World of Blood Series games was also removed from Facebook.

A look at the reasons why and the timeline of events leading up to the removal:

The Royal East India Trading Company website, which once praised it’s World of Blood Series, has been removed and is now a text message saying, “Beautiful. Just Beautiful. I applaud you, stranger. If we are in the same game, we should be friends. Tell me your name.” In addition, all references to the Royal East India Trading Company from any of the World of Blood Series applications or pages (that remain) have been removed. However, Patrick Shyu continues to have World of Blood listed as a current project for MySpace and Facebook on the “about” page of his website.

On the Facebook Developer Forum, in thread Elven Blood (and the 3 other “clones”) gone?, post #5, April 6, 2009, Matt Trainer, Facebook Platform Developer Operations & Support, says,

Hello Andy and others,

If you have evidence of any apps still available on Platform that are operated by Patrick Shyu, then please let us know.

To reiterate an earlier post, there are more enforcements on Platform than you are aware of, since Facebook does not publicize enforcement actions.

Cheers,

Matt Trainer

It would seem that not only were the World of Blood Series applications in trouble, but any other application operated by Patrick Shyu.

However, following the trail of events that would lead to the removal of the World of Blood Series applications, it becomes apparent that the World of Blood Series applications were having difficulties much earlier back in December, 2008 with reported potential Platform violations. In a thread titled Anyone gonna enforce the platform policies on Snowball Fight? in the Facebook Developer Forum, user zerostar07 reported a possible Platform violation in post #55, on December 16, 2008,

“notification from city of blood wrote: … ‘New! Join the holiday fun with your friends! Give some Christmas treats! 7:09pm’”

This just arrived from ‘City of blood’

the link goes to this application: http://www.facebook.com/apps/applicatio … 9548357635

some things never change

Matt Trainer’s response was as follows,

Hi George,

While this is certainly suspicious, we cannot take action without more detailed information (screenshots, URLs, and other proof).

We’d like to thank everyone again for staying alerted to bad apps like these. We’re aware that most developers on Facebook are honest and working to build good value for users, and so we are working on ways to better pinpoint and remove bad actors from the ecosystem.

We’re reviewing ideas brought up here and internally in order to best encourage positive use and limit negative use of Platform. We appreciate your continued discussions here.

We’re devoted to staying ahead of those who are abusing the system. You may not always see the results of these efforts, but we hope you continue to have faith in our commitment to the task.

Cheers,

Matt Trainer

So even back in December, 2008 the World of Blood Series was being observed.

Regarding Snowball Wars, the application was providing incentives to rate the game 5 out of 5 stars, which in the above referenced thread, Matt Trainer in post #6, December 9, 2008, states is a violation of Rule 3.1 of the Platform Policy Wiki,

“1. Application developers cannot trade positive reviews or collude with others to post, incentivize, or otherwise “game” the posting of negative or positive reviews. Applications should stand on their own merits based on user feedback, not insider quid pro quos.”

Snowball Wars was subsequently disabled, by post #16, December 9, 2008, although it was allowed to continue with a new ID and database and potential violations continued to be reported even after the new ID. The connection? Snowball Wars, and the related applications, were also developed by Patrick Shyu and the Royal East India Trading Company.

The Elven Blood Group wall’s postings fill in some of the gaps from December, 2008 to April, 2009 (the official Facebook Elven Blood discussion board has been removed, therefore the reliance upon the Elven Blood Group’s wall and other related groups). All dates unless otherwise noted are from 2009 and according to abridged reports by Facebook users.

  • -February 22, 5:05 am – the World of Blood Series applications are not available for the first time.
  • -February 22, 10:47 pm – Elven Blood has been renamed Twilight of Dragons.
  • -February 23, 2:26 am – Blood Lust has been renamed Nightfall.
  • -February 23, 6:31 pm – Elven Blood is back to its original name.
  • -February 25, 11:24 pm – Elven Blood is again unavailable.
  • -March 23, 4:39 pm – Elven Blood is back up.
  • -April 9, 12:33 pm – World of Blood is removed from Facebook completely.

Checking this line of events against the anti-World of Blood Series group, Blood Games: Boycott!, the only discrepancy seems that on April 9, 12:23 pm Elven Blood might have lived once more as Twilight of Dragons before being removed completely. Although on April 9, 2009 it appears that all World of Blood Series applications have been removed, Matt Trainer’s post from April 6, 2009 seems to indicate that actions were already being taken against applications operated by Patrick Shyu, however due to the wall activity in the group Twilight of Dragons Forum’s Wall it does appear that Twilight of Dragons and Elven Blood may have been running concurrently between March 23 – April 9, 2009, but the exact dates are uncertain.

Using the above referenced threads, posts, and groups, it seems the following were alleged/potential Platform violations:

  • -Users gaining Stamina in return for sending out invites to other Facebook users
  • -Use of copyrighted materials and images without permission, attribution, or payment
  • -Cross-promoting other applications via notifications
  • -Alleged extortion – freezing a user’s account for “cheating” and requiring payment of 15 blessings, which may only be available through participation in a sponsored advertisement or via purchase of blessings with a cash payment

In the end, it appears that not only World of Blood but any other application operated by Patrick Shyu are either on a warning list of sorts, or have been removed from Facebook. Considering the convoluted process it took from warnings to removal, combined with the lack of clear ownership and potentially shaky business activities, it seems that there remains more to be uncovered behind the removal of the World of Blood Series applications from Facebook.

However, while the World of Blood Series applications are no more on Facebook, they are still available on MySpace, attributed to the user ~World of Blood~.

Should any additional information come to light, or additional articles covering this topic, updates and links will be posted below.


Recent Posts
  • Imagine Life with a Pay-Per… by David Angel

    Can you imagine what life would be like if public utilities like electricity and water were run by U.S. Internet and wireless companies? Anyone want to sign up for a watt-hour plan, or would you care to buy water in bulks of 100 gallons? We already buy tired wireless data plans. Some [...]

  • The Veteran-Canine Connection by David Angel

    “Soldiers Saving Puppies * Puppies Saving Soldiers” The above header is the slogan of The Puppy Rescue Mission (TPRM), an organization whose slogan describes its mission perfectly. TPRM assists soldiers serving abroad bring their companions back home with them. However, the process can be expensive and so TPRM helps soldiers by [...]

  • Interface List: file opens … by David Angel

    Problem A file called [User Name] attempts to open after starting up Windows 7.  Selecting WordPad opens a document, where the first words read “Interface List.” My [User Name] file said (with some characters removed): ========================================================== Interface List 14…[characters removed] ……Bluetooth Device (Personal Area Network) 12…[characters removed] ……Broadcom 4322AG 802.11a/b/g/draft-n Wi-Fi [...]

  • A New Conversation about Im… by David Angel

    Stand With Me, Jose Antonio Vargas, for a New Conversation about Immigration Change.org recently sent an email reminder out about a pledge for a new conversation about immigration, started by Jose Antonio Vargas and Define American. “I Pledge to Define American I pledge. Like Jose Antonio Vargas, I believe that our nation’s [...]

  • Save Federal Funding for Bi… by David Angel

    Received this email from peopleforbikes.org This is Urgent! Federal funding for bicycling and walking is in jeopardy. We need you to send a short email today to your members of Congress. Today, Congressman John Mica of Florida, Chairman of the House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee, outlined his plans for the new [...]

  • “You White Motherfuck… by David Angel

    In my mind I wonder, why did you say to me, “get your bike out of the parking lot you white motherfucker”? Why did you feel it was necessary to add “you white motherfucker”?  Did it displease you that I was biking through that particular parking lot?  Did you feel [...]

  • Jumper Cable Confusion: Bla… by David Angel

    Jumper cables seem to match the color convention of car batteries. Red for positive, black for negative. The clamps are colored to ensure that you match positive-to-positive and negative-to-negative. However, in (my) instructions the black cable in the diagram represents the red jumper cable and the white cable in the [...]

  • Survey on Cycling Around th… by David Angel

    I received this cycling survey from the College of Cycling listserv, so if you’re a Chicagoan consider filling it out (link to survey below). Friends, As part of our Bicycle Plan for the 1st Ward of Chicago, Jack Eskin, Che Copper-Davis and I are putting together a survey of people who ride, [...]

  • Bike the Drive 2011 by David Angel

    Although thunderstorms were in the forecast, the inclement weather held off just long enough for Bike the Drive.  The heavy fog created an otherworldly feel down Lake Shore Drive and created a beautiful landscape to bike through.  The Field Museum and Museum of Science and Industry both looked quite amazing [...]

  • Building a Road Bike, Part 2: How? by David Angel

    (Building a Road Bike, Part 1: Why?) It took me much longer to get around to Part 2 than expected, and so it is going to be a bit shorter than I originally intended.  However, I think this will make my explanation on “How?” more concise and poignant. The first [...]

Categories
Recent Comments
Welcome , today is Tuesday, May 22, 2012